DISCLAIMER: This post is a general overview of DEI in light of recent bans. It is not legal advice and can be considered attorney advertising. If you have concerns about your DEI initiatives, please make an appointment with an attorney of your choosing and in your jurisdiction.
In the United States, Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) commitment is undergoing significant and rapid change. Recent Executive Orders (EOs) at the federal level and a growing number of state-level bans are understandably causing concern and uncertainty for private companies and individuals dedicated to fostering inclusive and equitable environments. We understand why this can feel disheartening. We feel it, too. Yet we also understand the legal and social limitations that can still be employed.
While the boundaries might be redefined, the fundamental importance and ethical imperative of DEI remain. You are not alone in your commitment, and you are certainly not helpless. Some businesses that pulled back on their DEI efforts are now realizing its impact and are changing course. Others are reforming their programs to avoid them being characterized as illegal or divisive.
Beyond the Headlines
It’s easy to feel overwhelmed by the broad strokes of the EOs and state bans. However, experts expect their impact to be on “illegal” or “divisive” DEI programs. Let’s break down the potential impact on private companies and individuals:
- Federal Executive Orders. The federal EOs primarily target federal government agencies and contractors. Their direct legal impact on most private sector organizations is currently limited, although the Department of Justice’s directive to criminally investigate those who promote DEI is concerning.
- State-Level Bans. These bans generally focus on DEI programs in public institutions like state agencies and universities. They restrict actions such as mandatory DEI training, establishment of DEI offices, and hiring preferences that the US Supreme Court already struck down.
What the Changes Don’t Mean
Outside of government agencies, the bans have greatest impact on private companies and educational institutions that depend on government funding or contracts. Most private entities are still free to address:
- Voluntary DEI initiatives. Training and initiatives that align with anti-discrimination laws are not only legal, they are still highly recommended.
- The business case for DEI. Especially in diverse workforces, inclusive cultures and equitable practices are crucial. They increase innovation, improve decision-making, advance employee engagement, and enhance reputations.
- The moral imperative for DEI. The fundamental belief in fairness, equal opportunity, and the value of every individual remains a guiding principle for many organizations and the individuals that work in them.
Clear Steps You Can Take
Despite the changing landscape, there are concrete, legally sound actions you can take to continue fostering DEI within your organizations and communities:
- Focus on Inclusion. Shift your focus to creating a universally inclusive environment that benefits everyone. Frame your efforts around principles like respect, psychological safety, and equitable access to opportunities for all employees, regardless of background.
- Emphasize Skills-Based Hiring and Promotion. Ensure your decision-making is based on clearly defined, job-related skills, qualifications, and experience.
- Invest in Anti-Bias Training. Unconscious bias training and training on inclusive communication can help create a more equitable workplace without focusing on legally restricted concepts. Frame this training around fostering a respectful and collaborative work environment.
- Conduct Pay Equity Audits. Proactively analyze your compensation practices to identify and address any statistically significant disparities based on gender, race, or other protected characteristics.
- Strengthen Your Code of Conduct. Reinforce your commitment to a respectful and inclusive workplace through a clear code of conduct that prohibits discrimination and harassment.
- Focus on Data and Measurement. Focus on collecting data to understand your workforce and identify areas for improvement in creating a positive work environment for all.
- Communicate Your Values Clearly. Articulate your organization’s commitment to a respectful and inclusive workplace in your mission statement, values, internal communications, and daily actions.
- Seek Legal Counsel. Engage with legal experts in each of the states where you have employees or workers who could be deemed your employees.
Moving Forward with Intention
The current climate requires a thoughtful and strategic approach to DEI. While some of the language and frameworks may need to adapt, the underlying principles of fairness, equity, and inclusion remain vital for building thriving organizations and a more just society.
Don’t let the headlines deter your commitment. By focusing on inclusion, skills-based practices, anti-bias training, and clear communication, you can continue to cultivate a workplace where everyone feels valued, respected, and has the opportunity to succeed. Your dedication to DEI matters, and by acting thoughtfully and within the bounds of the law, you can continue to make a meaningful difference.
Have more questions?
Register for Our Webinar Series with Spectra Diversity