• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

Third Ear Conflict Resolution

A holistic law firm helping employers create more peaceful and productive workplaces since 2003..

  • Schedule a Consultation
  • About
    • The Firm
    • WBE Capability Statement
    • Nance L. Schick
    • Media Relations
  • Services
    • Penalty Resolution
    • Employment Mediation
    • Informal Resolution Facilitation
    • Title IX and EEO Investigations
    • Employment Arbitration
    • Continuing Education & Training
    • Workers Compensation Defense
  • Tools
    • DIYCR Book
    • DISC Assessment
    • Trainual
    • YouTube Channel
    • Conflict Resolution Resources
    • Recommended Reads
    • Resource Lists
    • Strategic Partners
  • Contact
    • Virtual Office
    • LinkedIn
  • Show Search
Hide Search

How to Identify a True Independent Contractor

Nance Schick · May 20, 2021 ·

Independent Contractors are exactly what their titles suggest. They are independent workers who are not employees of the people or entities they serve, and they provide their services under a contract that has been mutually agreed upon.

The contract is not always governing in New York.

The Workers’ Compensation Board (“WCB”) or Department of Labor (“DOL”) could decide that your contractor is an employee–and you could be harshly penalized–even if you and the contractor both want an independent relationship.

The workers Photo of Nance's WeWork Office with independent contractor equationat issue can be known as freelancers, independent agents, permalancers, subcontractors, and more.

Call them what you like, but if they have not established business entities to provide the services they are providing, you might be required to provide workers compensation (“WC”) and disability (“DB”) insurance.

You might be responsible for income tax withholdings, overtime pay, and payroll taxes.

You might even be responsible for providing the contract that details the services they will provide, despite the fact that they are the experts in the work to be done.

Gig Worker is Not a Valid Legal Classification.

Technology and the “gig economy” have made the distinctions between employees and independent contractors difficult to identify, and no industry is immune. NYS has been penalizing businesses of all sizes for misclassifying workers, and the costs can be in the tens of thousands, regardless of whether you’ve made an honest mistake and there was no actual harm.

Events that can trigger a DOL or WCB inquiry include:

  • A freelancer files a claim under the Freelance Isn’t Free Act (“FIFA”)
  • Your independent contractor begins to work beyond the scope of the original project, quits, and files for unemployment insurance (“UI”) benefits, listing you as an employer
  • Your outside sales representative is involved in an accident while going to or from a sales meeting
  • You register for an employer identification number and hire an employee
  • You incorporate your business or form a limited liability company (“LLC”) and run your first payroll, even if you only pay yourself

We encourage you to consult an attorney with experience defending worker misclassification issues to discuss your risks–before you hire individual workers and pay them under their social security numbers. You are at especially high risk of having individuals deemed your employees.


DISCLAIMER

This page and website contain attorney advertising and a general overview of employment conflicts that might arise when working with independent contractors. It is not legal advice. If you require information or advice applied to your unique situation, please make an appointment to discuss it with an attorney experienced with the subject matter. Don’t rely solely on what you read on the Internet. Ever.



Planning to hire help?

Request a Consultation


What Are Your Risks When Hiring a Freelancer?


Nance L. Schick, Esq. is an employment attorney, ethno-religious mediator, conflict resolution coach, and diversity trainer based in New York City. She keeps employers out of court and builds their conflict resolution skills so everyone has a better work experience. She also negotiates penalty settlements for employers who unintentionally misclassify their workers. She is creator of the Third Ear Conflict Resolution process, author of DIY Conflict Resolution: Seven Choices and Five Actions of a Master, and an award-winning entrepreneur, who has been acknowledged by Super Lawyers (ADR, 2018, 2019 & 2020), the New York Economic Development Corporation/B-Labs, U.S. Chamber of Commerce, Enterprising Women Magazine, Urban Rebound NY/Count Me In, The Kauffman Foundation, and more.

Penalty Resolution employment contracts, freelancing, gig economy, independent contractors, self-employment

About

Nance L. Schick Affiliates Blog Book Contact

The Seven Choices

Forgive Yourself Acknowledge Yourself Forgive the World Free the Emotions Clear Your Mind Assume Nothing Listen with Your Heart

The Five Actions

Define the Conflict Identify the Interests Play with the Possibilities Create the Future Stay on PARR

Attorney Advertising. Privacy Policy. Nance L. Schick © 2007–2023

  • Your Third Ear
  • Email
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn